← Policy Materials

Public Comment · Arbor Hills

Hot Wells, an Outside Expert, and 852 Children

by Trisha Kunst · data scientist and resident living less than one mile from Arbor Hills · delivered November 18, 2026

The public comment Trisha Kunst gave in person to the Washtenaw County Materials Management Planning Committee on November 18, 2026, at the meeting where GFL presented on its environmental compliance at Arbor Hills with EGLE and YCUA staff in the room. She set aside her prepared remarks to respond to the presentation. Both versions are below, followed by the four handouts given to every committee member and the questions emailed to committee members that morning.

  1. The comment, as delivered
  2. The prepared remarks
  3. The handouts given to every committee member
  4. The questions emailed to committee members

To: Washtenaw County Materials Management Planning Committee

From: Trisha Kunst, data scientist and resident less than 1 mile from Arbor Hills

Re: Hot gas wells at Arbor Hills, the outside expert offered to the committee, and the children at two nearby elementary schools

Delivered: November 18, 2026, Materials Management Planning Committee meeting (spoken, about two minutes)

The comment, as delivered

Hi everybody. I'm Trisha Kunst. I run arborhillsmonitor.org. I'm a local data scientist.

First I wanted to address some of the hot-well issues. They (EGLE) made it sound like it was back in 2021. It was then, but the clearest chemical signature of the oxidation happened in March of 2025. Not very long ago. [The methane-to-carbon-dioxide warning sign appeared in 2021 to 2022 and again in early 2025; see fact check item 8.]

Why does anybody care that trash is hot? The EPA told us in the early 2000s that for every 18 degrees (Fahrenheit) the temperature goes up, the NMOCs a landfill produces double. [Correction: this rule of thumb comes from ATSDR's 2001 Landfill Gas Primer, not EPA; see fact check item 10.] That's an exponential rate. So every time the temperature goes up, the neighbors are exposed to more NMOC emissions. That's the problem with hot wells.

All of you received the personal cell phone number of a senior engineer who worked on Chiquita Canyon. You were asked to call him and educate yourselves. He offered to brief the commissioners. As of today, nobody has called him.

I'd also like to point out that there are two elementary schools, not one, with 852 children. That means Arbor Hills wins the bronze: it ranks third in Michigan for the number of elementary children going to school less than a mile from a landfill. And one personal question… [The chair called time.]

Trisha Kunst
Data scientist, resident less than 1 mile from Arbor Hills
[email protected]

Lightly edited for clarity; corrections in brackets [ ].

  • 852 children is the Spring 2026 state headcount for Salem Elementary (401 students) and Ridge Wood Elementary (451 students), both less than one mile from the landfill. The number counts students enrolled at the two schools, not children living nearby. Of the 45 Michigan Type II landfills measured, two have more elementary students that close, which puts Arbor Hills third. That ranking counts every student at one Granger school, including grades 6 to 8. If counting grades K to 5 only, Arbor Hills would move up to second.

The prepared remarks

I'm Trisha Kunst, a local data scientist. I run arborhillsmonitor.org.

There is no capacity problem. Even with no new landfill, Washtenaw's trash would not have to travel more than 50 miles for about 16 to 18 years. And the truck emissions saved by a shorter haul are small next to the landfill gas a new landfill would release for decades.

Meanwhile, the burden is already here. On September 28th and 29th, GFL's consultant installed two passive vents east of Napier Road. Since then, they have released soil gas straight into the open air. The last time that gas was tested for toxic compounds, in June 2024, it held chloroform about 70 times EPA's screening level for soil gas under homes. No test of what the vents release is on record.

In the groundwater, GFL itself proposed testing for PFAS, including PFOS, in July 2023, to start once EGLE approved. That testing has never started. Please use the leverage the county already has under its 2017 host agreement to get it started.

852 children attend Salem Elementary and Ridge Wood Elementary, both less than a mile from the waste.

So what is left? The money. Almost five million dollars a year: about 1.3 to 1.4 million for Washtenaw County, and about 3.5 million for Salem Township.

For how long must residents, and those 852 children, carry the burden of this revenue?

Notes on the prepared remarks

  • The July 2023 PFAS testing plan was submitted under an EGLE consent order (MMD Consent Order 115-05-2023).
  • "Never started" rests on the record: in response to a public-records request (FOIA E613160), EGLE reported no approval of the plan and no groundwater PFAS results after April 2023.
  • The truck emissions rest on an unpublished estimate that has not been through independent review.
  • Of Salem Township's roughly $3.5 million (fiscal year ending March 31, 2025, as reported by the Detroit Free Press, Jan. 7, 2026), about $2.6 million is landfill-gas revenue from the existing landfill, which would continue for some time after the landfill stopped taking waste. The county figure is from the committee's July 8 and September 9, 2026 meeting slides.

The handouts given to every committee member

Four printed handouts went to each committee member at the meeting. They are posted here exactly as printed.

The questions emailed to committee members

Only committee members can ask questions at a Materials Management Planning Committee meeting. At 7:00 AM on November 18, Trisha emailed these questions to committee members, with copies to the county staff and planning consultant who support the committee (three copies bounced and were resent at 9:05 AM), asking that a member read one or more of them aloud while GFL, EGLE and YCUA were present. The email text is reproduced below; addresses are omitted.

Every figure in the comment, the handouts and the questions traces to a primary regulatory record or a named source. The underlying wellfield data, EGLE filings, and interactive visualizations are published at Arbor Hills Monitor.